Toyo Celsius II vs Firestone Weathergrip tires

Toyo, the Japan-based tire manufacturer was established in 1945 and offers tires for passenger cars, light trucks, CUVs, SUVs, electric vehicles, and ATVs/UTVs. Toyo offers different types of tires that include all-season, all-terrain, all-weather, UHP all-season, UHP summer, rugged-terrain, mud-terrain, and various others. The first tire that we have picked for comparison today is the Celsius II which comes from this popular tire manufacturer in the American subcontinent.

Firestone, on the other hand, has a long history and was founded way back in 1900. This American tire manufacturer is now a part of the Bridgestone family and is also an OE supplier to various popular manufacturers. It offers tires for use on passenger cars, CUVs, SUVs, light trucks, farm applications, commercial vehicles, and various other vehicle types. Its tire portfolio consists of tires of various types including all-season, all-weather, UHP summer, UHP all-season, winter, all-terrain, mud-terrain, rugged-terrain, and others. The second tire that we have picked comes from Firestone – the Weathergrip!

So, before we resume with the comparative analysis of Celsius II vs Weathergrip tires, let’s go over some basics first:

• Both Celsius II and Weathergrip are all-weather tires.
• Both are Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified and therefore, are qualified for use in dry, wet, and severe winter conditions.
• They can be used in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit, which makes them a true and better year-round performing tire than the all-season tires.
• Both tires are good for use on various vehicle types including passenger vehicles, coupes, sedans, and CUVs.

If you’re looking for a reliable all-weather tire for your drive, and have shortlisted Celsius II and Weathergrip tires, our comparative analysis will help you choose the perfect tire that matches your driving style and needs. This comparison of Celsius II and Weathergrip tires will explain in detail how both tires stand overall, and in terms of traction, handling, and longevity, using our advanced tire rating system SimpleScore. So, read on!

Toyo Celsius II tires

Let’s understand a few things about Toyo Celsius II, the first tire that we have picked for comparison. This all-weather tire is suitable for use on CUVs, SUVs, and passenger cars, and was launched in February 2023 and comes loaded with many features and technologies that contribute to enhancing driving performance in dry, wet, and winter weather. There are dedicated features and technologies that improve traction, cornering, braking, stability, and acceleration, and increase tread life. Additionally, there’s an attractive warranty coverage that makes the ownership experience great.

Overall, the Celsius II scores an admirable 8.8 SimpleScore out of 10, thanks to its long-lasting tread life, responsive handling, and exceptional traction.

GET TOYO CELSIUS II TIRES AT THE BEST DEALS FOR YOUR VEHICLE HERE.

Firestone Weathergrip tires

Now, let’s discuss a few details about the Firestone Weathergrip, the second tire picked for the comparative analysis. This all-weather tire made its debut in May 2019 and is good for use on coupes, sedans, CUVs, and minivans. It is the result of Firestone’s great engineering efforts that the tire offers reliable wet performance, comfortable rides, solid snow traction, and great performance on wet as well as dry surfaces. Like its peer, the Weathergrip tire also comes backed by an attractive limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

Overall, the Weathergrip achieves an impressive 8.7 SimpleScore because of its excellent tread life, superior traction, and sharp handling.

GET FIRESTONE WEATHERGRIP TIRES AT THE BEST DEALS FOR YOUR VEHICLE HERE.

Toyo Celsius II vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on traction

To understand how both Celsius II and Weathergrip tires perform when it comes to road grip and surefootedness in varying weather conditions, let’s compare their traction performance.

The Toyo Celsius II scores an 8.8 SimpleScore in traction, confirming that the tire is good for us in all weathers. The Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification adds to the all-weather performance factor and makes the tire eligible for use even in moderate to severe winter conditions. The optimized tread design of the tire features a good number of sipes and zigzag-shaped tread blocks for enhanced winter traction. The interlocking multi-wave sipes on the outer tread improve dry traction. The silica compound used in the tread improves wet and dry grip, alongside maintaining flexibility in wintry conditions. There are snow claws on the tread that dig into snow to firmly hold the surface and the slush grooves disperse slush and snow for consistent surefootedness.

The Firestone Weathergrip also doesn’t disappoint with its traction performance and scores an 8.7 SimpleScore rating in traction. Thanks to the open shoulder slots and zigzag grooves water is effectively evacuated from the footprint and hydroplaning is remarkably controlled for a confident wet weather driving. The 3D full-depth sipes of the Weathergrip tire are optimized to boost traction performance in snowy conditions. The use of Snow Traction Claw Technology further improves traction in slick and snowy conditions. The tread compound of the tire is also optimized to withstand changing weather conditions.

No doubt the Weathergrip tires are great, but the Celsius II tires take the lead by a small margin.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Celsius II

Toyo Celsius II vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on handling

Next, let’s take a look at the handling performances of both tires and understand how are they when it comes to steering response, lane change, cornering, stability, braking performance, and overall controllability.

Starting with the Celsius II, the tire scores an 8.8 SimpleScore rating in handling, which confirms its ability to offer great controllability in all weathers. The tire balances well in wet and dry conditions because of interlocking multi-wave sipes on the outer tread. The silica compound also assists in keeping the tire glued to the surface. The outer portion of the asymmetric tread pattern of the tire enhances cornering, acceleration, and braking, while the flat and wider footprint maintains optimum stability.

Contrarily, the Weathergrip tire scores an 8.6 SimpleScore rating on the handling front, which is also impressive enough to prove that the tire is capable of responding to the driver’s commands right on time. Thanks to the wide and flat tread footprint that ensures optimum stability, the sipes help maintain a solid grip on dry, wet, and snowy conditions. The solid shoulders of the tire are extended enough to provide better control while cornering and the ribs allow the tire to easily maneuver from one lane to the other. The silica compound additionally contributes to improved controllability by keeping the tread flexible and glued enough in varying temperatures.

In the handling area as well the Celsius II tires surpass the Weathergrip tires, confirming their slightly better ability to offer better controllability in changing seasons.

ADVANTAGE: Toyo Celsius II

Toyo Celsius II vs Firestone Weathergrip tires on longevity

All want tires that last longer and perform better, while we have gone through the performance parameters of traction and handling, now let’s take a look at the long-lasting ability of the Celsius II and Weathergrip tires.

The Celsius II scores a 9.0 SimpleScore rating in longevity and is covered by a 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, which indicates that the tire is built and designed to offer a worry-free driving experience for a good number of miles. The asymmetric tread pattern of the tire is engineered to enable cross rotation and reduce the chances of irregular wear, while the solid inner casing and tough rubber compound reduce the wear rate. Even the sidewalls are durable enough to withstand the loads and pressures, thus keeping the tire always in shape and promoting longevity.

On the other hand, the Weathergrip surprises with an exceptional 9.2 SimpleScore in longevity. This signals that the Weathergrip is made tough and sturdy to offer a long-lasting tread life. Besides this, the tire also comes with a 65,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty that further looks convincing to analyze the long-lasting ability of the tire. The 3D full-depth sipes on the tread reduce the chances of uneven wear for a longer service, while the solid inner and outer construction allow the tire to withstand the driving pressures and cover more miles, and avoid the chances of premature wear.

In longevity, things differ a lot as the Weathergrip comes out as a leader here, scoring better than the Celsius II.

ADVANTAGE: Firestone Weathergrip

When to use each

Both, Celsius II tires and Weathergrip tires are good for use in dry and wet conditions, and since they are Three Peak Mountain Snowflake-certified, they can also be used in moderate to severe winter weather conditions, in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. It is to be noted that these tires are built and designed for use on paved roads and should not be considered for off-road use. Additionally, if you live in an area with snowfall for more than 6 months a year, considering winter tires could be a better choice over all-weather tires.

Talking about the rim sizes, the Celsius II is good for vehicles that have rims falling between 15- to 22-inch, while the Weathergrip is suitable for use on vehicles with rims in the range of 15- to 19-inch.

Which one should you choose?

Looking at the overall SimpleScores, the Toyo Celsius II tires appear to be a better choice with a slightly better overall rating of 8.8 as compared to Firestone Weathergrip’s 8.7 SimpleScore rating. But, since both tires have their strengths, it’s better to analyze them first and make a purchase decision.

As far as prices are concerned, the Celsius II is available at an initial price of at least $102.99 per tire, while the Weathergrip’s starting price is at least $130.99 per tire. This means that a set of four Celsius II tires will cost you at least $411.96 and a set of four Weathergrip tires will be available at a price of at least $523.96.

Based on SimpleScores, you should choose the Celisus II if you:

• Drive a luxury CUV like the Volvo XC40, an SUV like the Chevrolet Tahoe, or a wagon like the older Honda Crosstour
• Need tires that are better in traction
• Need tires that are better in handling
• Need tires that are suitable for use on rims ranging between 15- to 22-inch
• Need tires that are not only better overall but also come at a comparatively cheaper price

Contrarily, you should consider the Weathergrip if you:

• Drive a hybrid like the Toyota Prius, a 2-row CUV like the Honda CR-V, or a luxury CUV like the Honda CR-V
• Need long-lasting tires
• Need tires for vehicles with rim sizes ranging between 15- to 19-inch
• Need tires that are backed by a 65,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty
• Are comfortable paying more to own a set of solid Firestone-branded tires

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.