Compare
Free shipping
Best price guarantee
Special pricing
Financing with Resolve
Easy returns
Last updated 12/17/2024 - Originally published 12/17/2024
Written by SimpleTire
The US market has been a sweet spot for manufacturers of all-season tires since they account for more than 90% of all passenger car tire sales. With its racing pedigree, Pirelli Tire has been instrumental in producing some outstanding all-season tires that offer terrific control, exceptional traction, and fantastic tread life.
On the other hand, the American tire manufacturer Firestone, though currently owned by Bridgestone, offers a mix of quality, durability, and performance across its tires for CUVs, passenger cars, SUVs, commercial vehicles, and pickup trucks. While Pirelli has been in the US since the 1920s, Firestone has the privilege of being the older brand, being in the market since 1900. If you're looking at a comparison between two exceptional all-season tires, it would be a good idea to go through this comparison piece.
While both tires are great in traction, handling, comfort, control, and durability in their own ways, the Pirelli tire appears to be the better one at the outset, but don't take our word for it. Both the P4 Persist AS Plus and All-Season are supported by strong limited manufacturer tread life warranties. Both show special features for decreasing road noise and symmetrical tread patterns, though the tread depth on the Firestone All-Season is slightly higher.
To help you choose an ideal year-round partner for your sedan, coupe, minivan, SUV, and CUV, our SimpleScore approach would be most helpful. Let's compare the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus with Firestone All-Season to identify the winner.
Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus tires
The Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus boasts outstanding traction, grip, handling, and stability all year long. The Pirelli all-season tire's deep grooves rapidly remove water, therefore lowering the risk of hydroplaning and improving wet performance. Although the notched center rib provides outstanding handling and stability with more control, its optimal pitch sequence greatly lowers road noise and vibration levels to restore a peaceful and comfortable ride experience. The thick sipes allow the all-season tire to have more biting edges for good grip and traction in mild to wet snow. Designed with a unique rubber compound, it reduces unequal wear and advances consistent wear all through its lifetime. A strong 85,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty supports it and guarantees long-lasting tread life.
With an outstanding 9.3 average score, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus has several qualities that help it qualify as a perfect all-season tire.
Firestone All-Season tires
Launched in 2017, the Firestone All-Season is known for providing enhanced grip, traction, and handling on paved roads in different weather conditions. More comfortable than its predecessor, the Firestone All-Season has a refined tread pattern meant to lower noise and vibration levels. On paved roads, the symmetric tread design with wavy sipes helps greatly with handling and stability in addition to increasing grip and traction. The Firestone tire returns more control and improved handling in many weather conditions all year long with an upgraded rubber formula and deep sipes. While standard sizes have a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, CUV tire sizes are available as per a warranty of 55,000 miles. Additionally, Firestone provides a 90-day Buy and Try Guarantee on tires sold in sets of four or more.
For all its qualities, the Firestone All-Season qualifies for an average SimpleScore of 8.4.
Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Firestone All-Season tires on traction
One of the main purposes of a tire is traction since it is directly related to performance. Both the P4 Persist AS Plus and All-Season can provide great traction and grip.
Thanks to its wide circumferential grooves that remove water from the tread to reduce the risk of hydroplaning and improve wet performance, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus offers outstanding grip and traction, generating additional biting edges on wet and snowy surfaces through the dense sipes. As per the above, the P4 Persist AS Plus receives an amazing average traction score of 9.4.
On the other hand, for a tire meant for year-round driveability, the Firestone All-Season has an average traction score of 8.3. Over seasons that include light snow, the special deep sipes and special rubber formulation of this all-season tire considerably enhance grip and braking performance.
ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus
Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Firestone All-Season tires on handling
Another important factor of a tire is handling since it controls the vehicle and reduces the possibility of any accident by understeer or oversteer.
With its notched center rib and optimized tread pattern that increases steering response and stability on all driving surfaces, the P4 Persist AS Plus continues its amazing run and gets a tremendous average handling score of 9.1 out of 10.
Conversely, the Firestone All-Season shows significantly less handling ability. Its improved tread design greatly lessens road vibrations and noises, thereby ensuring comfortable rides. Deep sipes and the tire compound help drivers enjoy consistent handling in many circumstances all year long. As per the above, the Firestone All-Season manages an average handling score of 8.3.
ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus
Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus vs Firestone All-Season tires on longevity
All-season tires are largely chosen for their longer manufacturer's tread life warranties and great service life, both of which can be seen on the Pirelli and Firestone tires.
For consistent wear, the P4 Persist AS Plus boasts an ideal tread design that equally distributes the driving pressure over the contact patch. The Pirelli tire's unique rubber compound resists unequal wear and extends tread life. Amazing long-term performance and great durability are two great characteristics of the P4 Persist AS Plus, along with the strong 85,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. Given the above, the Persist AS Plus boasts a truly outstanding average longevity score of 9.6.
The Firestone All-Season showcases a unique rubber compound and tread pattern that reduce unequal wear and extend the service life. While normal tire sizes here are backed by a 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, CUV sizes are covered by a 55,000 mile warranty. Based on the above, the Firestone All-Season receives a great average longevity score of 8.6.
ADVANTAGE: Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus
When to use each
Apart from great handling, comfort, grip, and longevity in different weather conditions, generous limited manufacturer tread life warranties and long service lives define all-season tires. Other than being brilliant at performance and traction, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus also offers a very high limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
Make sure you buy all-weather tires that are designed for erratic weather conditions, especially moderate to harsh cold. On the other hand, consider winter tires if the temperatures stay below 45 degrees Fahrenheit around the year or for several months a year since they are designed to last in sub-freezing weather without any dip in performance. Since these tires wear faster, they cannot be utilized in hot surroundings.
Which one should you choose?
In the end, we noticed that the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus is way ahead of the Firestone All-Season in terms of traction, handling, and longevity. However, Firestone’s 90-day Buy and Try guarantee is a good reason to buy it too. Let’s compare their prices to get a clearer understanding of the two.
For the 195/65R15 91H tire size, the Pirelli costs roughly $123 per tire ($492 for 4), while the Firestonel tire costs approximately $115 per tire ($460 for 4) (a difference of $8 per tire).
Based on SimpleScores, you can pick the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus if you:
- Drive vehicles like the Honda CR-V, Volvo XC60, and Hyundai Santa Fe
- Prefer better traction and handling
- Are interested in a longer limited manufacturer tread life warranty
You can go for the Firestone All-Season if you:
- Drive vehicles like the Chevrolet Impala, Toyota Corolla, or Honda CR-V
- Like Firestone’s 90-day Buy and Try Guarantee on tires sold in sets of four or more
- Want a quieter and more comfortable ride
Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.