Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Haida HD878 R/T tires

Headquartered in Illinois, Atturo is known for offering solid tires used for daily driving and off-roading purposes. With over 80 years of expertise in making tires, Atturo has been catering to the needs of light trucks, passenger cars, ATVs/UTVs, and trailers. Its portfolio includes UHP summer, mud-terrain, all-terrain, rugged-terrain, and all-season tires.

Haida, on the other hand, is a China-based tire manufacturer that offers tires for use on passenger cars, SUVs, light trucks, specialty vehicles, and commercial trucks and buses. The different types of tires offered by the manufacturer include UHP summer, all-season, mud-terrain, rugged-terrain, winter, all-terrain, and highway.

Coming from Atturo and Haida, the Trail Blade X/T and the HD878 R/T are the two respective rugged-terrain tires suitable for use on light trucks, Jeeps, and SUVs, which we will be comparing here. This will help you understand which of the two tires is better in areas like traction, handling, and longevity, utilizing our SimpleScore tire rating system.

To give you context, rugged-terrain tires combine the abilities of all-terrain and mud-terrains, allowing you to enjoy confident off-roading and ride on paved roads. Compared to all-terrain tires, these tires offer better off-roading ability. So, let’s compare the Trail Blade X/T vs HD878 R/T tires and find out which one you should consider.

Atturo Trail Blade X/T tires

Launched in November 2022, Atturo Trail Blade X/T is a reliable hybrid of mud-terrain and all-terrain tires that scores an overall 7.7 SimpleScore rating and assures of reliable off-road and decent on-road performance. The tire features larger mud-terrain shoulder blocks, reinforced sidewall, and aggressive center tread pattern blocks that enhance both off-roading and daily driving experience. The tire offers quieter rides, dependable traction, enhanced steering response, and better on-road stability in rainy and light snowy conditions. Additionally, a tread life warranty adds more value to the purchase.

Get Atturo Trail Blade X/T tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Haida HD878 R/T tires

Haida HD878 R/T is also a good tire that scores an overall 7.3 SimpleScore rating and can be trusted for its year-round traction and strong performance on- and off-road. This rugged-terrain tire features an aggressive tread and a self-cleaning tread pattern. The build and design are optimized for damage resistance and there are also some great features contributing to enhanced handling performance. Long-lasting tread life, tear and wear resistance, and strength to combat rough conditions make the tire a reliable choice. However, it lacks a tread life warranty coverage.

Get Haida HD878 R/T tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Haida HD878 R/T tires on traction

The traction analysis of rugged-terrain tires is also important as it relates to surface-biting abilities on and off the road. When we compared the Trail Blade X/T and the HD878 R/T tires, both tires looked competitive, however, there was one that scored marginally higher on SimpleScore.

Let’s talk about the Trail Blade X/T first, the tire earns a 7.5 SimpleScore rating for traction and can perform well on smooth as well as rough roads. However, the lack of Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certification means it cannot perform in moderate to severe winter weather conditions. The tire features tread blocks with alternating sipes for enhanced snow traction, while the larger shoulder blocks boost off-road performance. Additionally, the angled shoulder grooves increase traction on trails and the center tread blocks ensure good traction in wet and light snow conditions.

On the other hand, the HD878 R/T scores a 7.4 SimpleScore in traction, giving good competition to the Trail Blade tires. The tire features an all-season rubber compound and tread pattern that provides traction and grip in dry, wet, and light snow conditions, while the 3D tread pattern improves grip during on- and off-road drives. The wider profile provides an increased contact patch for extra traction and the self-cleaning ability cleans mud and snow from the tread for enhanced grip. Additionally, the shoulder tread area is also optimized for solid traction performance, especially in conditions like mud.

While both tires are good on the traction front, it is the Trail Blade X/T that beats the HD878 R/T by a small margin and leads.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade X/T

Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Haida HD878 R/T tires on handling

Handling is another important area that needs to be analyzed to understand the tire’s steering command, on-road lane-changing ability and stability, cornering performance, responsiveness in off-road conditions, and other things.

Scoring a solid 7.9, the Trail Blade X/T hints at a reliable handling performance on- and off-road. The tire features horizontal and vertical sipes that enhance handling performance in snow and reduce tread noise levels on paved roads. The shoulder blocks are large and the flat footprint provides good stability on- and off-road. There are angled shoulders that improve handling performance, and for more stable rides on the highways, it features center blocks that are linked together at their base. Furthermore, the smaller blocks at the center also improve ride control in snowy and rainy conditions.

Comparatively, the HD878 R/T scores 7.5 SimpleScore in handling, which confirms the tire’s dependable steering response. The shoulder tread pattern of the tire avoids skidding and improves handling performance on wet and slick surfaces, while the solid inner casing and robust rubber compound hold the tire in shape to boost steering response and allow the tire to combat off-roading pressures. Additionally, the wider tread footprint of the HD878 R/T is also engineered for enhanced stability and confident cornering in varying conditions.

Clearly, the Trail Blade X/T is a better tire here and scores more than the HD878 R/T.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade X/T

Atturo Trail Blade X/T vs Haida HD878 R/T tires on longevity

Now, moving on to another important area that will help you in making a better purchase decision – the longevity of the Trail Blade X/T and the HD878 R/T tires. This was the area where we saw a one-sided victory by one of these tires. Here are the details:

Commencing with the Trail Blade X/T, the tire offers a great long-lasting performance, as indicated by its 8.2 SimpleScore for longevity. The trust in the long-lasting service life is also boosted by the limited manufacturer tread life warranty of 45,000 miles. The reinforced “Knife Blade” tread blocks of the tire resist damage from cuts and chips, while the rim guard safeguards the sidewalls and wheels from curb damage. The Trail Blade X/T also features open shoulders and sturdy tread blocks that protect the casing from damage.

On the contrary, the HD878 R/T scores a 7.2 SimpleScore rating in longevity. This means the tire offers mediocre performance when it comes to service life. It has a special anti-collision sidewall that protects against punctures, pressure damage, and road collision damage. The construction and rubber compound are adequately durable to resist wear rate and offer longer service life.

The difference in the longevity of both tires can be seen from the gap in their scores. While the Haida rugged-terrain tire delivers average performance, the Trail Blade X/T is way better.

ADVANTAGE: Atturo Trail Blade X/T

When to use each

Both the Trail Blade X/T and the HD878 R/T are rugged-terrain tires and are optimized for year-round performance. They can be used in dry, wet, and light winter conditions and can tackle both highways and challenging terrains. However, they are not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified and should not be used in moderate to severe winter conditions, in temperatures below 45 degrees Fahrenheit. If you are particularly looking for tires that are suitable for use in deep mud and very aggressive off-road terrains, then mud-terrain tires could be a better choice.

Let’s talk about the tire sizes now. The Trail Blade X/T tires are available in 14- to 26-inch rim sizes, assuring increased compatibility with Jeeps, SUVs, and pickup trucks. Contrarily, the HD878 is available in 16- to 24-inch rim sizes.

Which one should you choose?

Based on the overall SimpleScore, it is the Trail Blade X/T that’s better than the HD878 R/T (7.7 vs 7.3 SimpleScore rating). The Trail Blade X/T also comes out as a winner in traction, handling, and longevity, earning additional creditability for its diversified performance. However, both tires are unique in their own ways and therefore, you must pick the tire that best aligns with your budget and driving needs.

Talking about the price, the Trail Blade X/T is available at a starting price of at least $128, while the HD878 R/T is available at an initial price of at least $165 per tire. This means a set of four Trail Blade X/T tires can be bought at a cost of at least $512, while a set of four HD878 R/T tires will cost you at least $660.

Looking at the SimpleScore, you should buy the Trail Blade X/T if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the GMC Yukon XL or Ford F-350.
• Want a tire that is better in traction (7.5 vs 7.4).
• Want a tire that is better in handling (7.9 vs 7.5) and lasts long (8.2 vs 7.2).
• Want a tire that is backed by a 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.
• Want a more affordable tire.
• Want a tire that’s compatible with more vehicles on the market.

On the other hand, you should choose the Terra Commander RTX if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the RAM 1500 or Chevrolet Suburban.
• Need a tire that’s offered in the rim size range of 16- to 24 inches.
• Are ready to spend more on a rugged-terrain tire.

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.