Armstrong Blu-Trac PC vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires

Armstrong Tires and Kelly Tires are two popular tire manufacturers known for their range of premium and performance-oriented tires. Armstrong was founded in 1912 and has grown to become the 5th largest tire manufacturer in the world. On the other hand, Kelly is one of the oldest names in the American tire industry and has been a part of the Goodyear family since 1935. Both brands offer a range of tires in different categories such as all-season, all-terrain, ultra-high-performance, winter, summer, all-weather, and many more.

All-season tires are known for their versatility and longevity. These tires are designed to offer consistent traction, responsive handling, and longer tread life in dry, wet, and light winter weather conditions, making them a popular choice among daily drivers. Today, we will look at two all-season tires from the brands - Armstrong Blu-Trac PC and Kelly Edge Touring A/S. We will discuss a few similarities and differences between these two great all-season tires designed for passenger vehicles in this Armstrong Blu-Trac PC vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tire comparison.

Armstrong Blu-Trac PC tires

The Armstrong Blu-Trac PC is an all-season tire designed for use on passenger vehicles and offers drivers improved stability and braking, smooth and comfortable ride, and consistent traction throughout the year. The tire is also backed by an 85,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty and Armstrong's 6-Year Limited Warranty, 30-Day Money Back Guarantee, and Mileage Warranty (conditions and restrictions applied).

Thanks to this great performance, the Armstrong Blu-Trac PC received an average SimpleScore of 8.5 out of 10.

Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires

The Kelly Edge Touring A/S is an all-season tire designed for use on passenger cars and offers drivers enhanced traction and a longer tread life. The tire is built with sweeping grooves, silica tread compound, biting tread block edges, and various other tire elements that enable it to deliver superior performance. The tire is also backed by a 65,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty and delivers a solid performance with 8.2 as its average SimpleScore.

Armstrong Blu-Trac PC vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on traction

Traction is crucial across all tire categories, determining how well a tire performs on both wet and dry surfaces. It plays a key role in maintaining vehicle control, particularly at high speeds or in slick conditions like water, slush, mud, snow, and ice. A tire's traction is shaped by its advanced rubber compound, tread design, and internal structure.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac PC received a 7.9 in traction thanks to the lateral grooves paired with chamfered edges that help reduce rolling resistance and simultaneously improve traction with the help of a self-locking sipe system that keeps the tire’s tread clean.

In traction, the Kelly Edge Touring A/S scored a 7.5 thanks to biting tread block edges and sweeping grooves that channel water and slush out of the tread for improved treadwear.

Both tires offer reasonable performance in traction on paved roads in wet, dry, and light winter conditions. However, based on SimpleScore the Blu-Trac PC scores better and is the winner here.

ADVANTAGE: Armstrong Blu-Trac PC

Armstrong Blu-Trac PC vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on handling

When buying a tire, it's vital to consider its handling, as this directly affects your control over the vehicle, especially at higher speeds. Quality handling ensures smooth maneuvering, effortless turning, and easy lane changes, greatly improving your driving experience. The tread design, rubber composition, and advanced technological features of the tire are key factors that influence its handling performance.

In handling, the Armstrong Blu-Trac PC received a great 8.2 thanks to the robust construction with wide shoulders and a large contact patch area. This helps put more rubber to the ground when driving straight or turning, ensuring responsive and consistent handling. Additionally, dynamic inner ribs help lower road noise for a quiet, comfortable ride.

The Kelly Edge Touring A/S received a great 8 in handling thanks to the symmetrical tread pattern that allows for a strong grip on the road to improve handling and cornering performance.

Again you can see the Armstrong tire taking the lead with slightly better SimpleScore.

ADVANTAGE: Armstrong Blu-Trac PC

Armstrong Blu-Trac PC vs Kelly Edge Touring A/S tires on longevity

When choosing tires, longevity is a key consideration for many drivers, as it dictates how long you can drive before requiring a replacement. As the tread wears over time, selecting tires with extended durability is essential for maintaining consistent handling and traction. Longevity is influenced by factors like tread pattern, rubber compound formulation, and the overall tire design.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac PC truly shines in longevity with an excellent score of 9.7 thanks to the symmetric tread design that promotes even wear for increased longevity. Additionally, the tire is backed by an exceptional 85,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

In longevity, the Kelly Edge Touring A/S received an impressive 9 thanks to the silica tread compound and angled tread blocks that help improve treadwear. Additionally, the tire is backed by a 65,000 miles limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

Again here the Armstrong Blu-Trac PC takes the lead with a much better SimpleScore and mileage warranty, making it the clear winner.

ADVANTAGE: Armstrong Blu-Trac PC

When to use each

Both Armstrong Blu-Trac PC and Kelly Edge Touring A/S are great all-season tires designed for use throughout the year in dry, wet, or light winter weather conditions. These tires are designed to deliver solid traction on wet and dry road surfaces and are most suited on paved roads. Additionally, as these tires are not Three Peak Mountain Snowflake certified, they should not be used in moderate to severe winter weather conditions, where winter tires are more suited.

Which one should you choose?

So which all-season tire might be the right fit for you? Well, the answer solely depends on your personal preference as both tires have their own set of advantages and disadvantages. For instance, the Armstrong tire scores better in all avenues delivering great overall performance. The Kelly Edge Touring A/S while lagging in SimpleScores as compared to the Armstrong tire, still delivers solid performance. Another important factor to consider before purchasing a tire is its price.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac PC costs $48.98 per tire or $195.92 for a set. Conversely, the Kelly Edge Touring A/S costs around $94.99 per tire or $379.96 for a set of the same size. (Note - Prices may vary depending on the tire size.)

Based on SimpleScore, you should purchase the Armstrong Blu-Trac PC if you:

• Drive a vehicle like the Ford Escape or a something like the Nissan Rogue
• Want a tire with better overall SimpleScore (8.5 v 8.2), handling (8.2 v 8), traction (7.9 v 7.5), and longevity (9.7 v 9)
• Prefer a tire that has a better mileage warranty (85,000 vs 65,000 miles)
• Want Armstrong's 6 Year Limited Warranty, 30-Day Money Back Guarantee, and Mileage Warranty
• Want a cheaper set of tires

On the other hand, you should choose the Kelly Edge Touring A/S if you:

• Drive a sedan like the Toyota Corolla, or a car like the Mazda 3
• Want a tire that offers a quiet, comfortable ride

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents will be more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.