Rims not included with purchase of tires

Carlstar Turf SaverReviews

Write a review
  • SimpleScore™

    Our proprietary rating system
    for the modern tire buyer.



    Score breakdown:


    Long lasting








  • 17 reviews

    17 on SimpleTire


    overall rating


    Would you buy again?

    Review breakdown

    • 12 out of 100
    • 4 out of 100
    • 1 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100

    Carlstar tires has been one of the premier suppliers of specialty tires, including industrial, OTR, ATV, construction, and lawn/turf tires. Carlstar's commitment is to top-quality specialty tires at an affordable price.

    This is a lawn and garden tire specially designed for those who are looking for minimal grass compaction and extended wear. But is this the right tire for you and your ride? Let’s take a look at this Carlstar Turf Saver review.

    Features and Benefits

    If you are looking for turf-friendly traction, versatility, and stability for your land. This tire is ideal for garden tractors, walk-behinds, golf carts, snow blowers, turf maintenance vehicles, and utility vehicles, as this tire has a tread that provides superior grip without damaging the grass underneath. Additionally, you see a flat profile and chevron tread that provides excellent traction. Its turf-friendly design and breadth of the line make it versatile in both application and fitment.

    Let’s take a look at the Carlstar Turf Saver tire review to help understand all its features and benefits at a glance:

    • Great durability: Constructed with broad-shouldered, puncture-resistant construction of high-quality materials. The robust construction enhances durability and contributes to a longer tread life.
    • Smooth and comfortable: Carlstar has integrated an extra wide footprint to ensure a smooth and comfortable driving experience.
    • Quiet ride: These tires effectively absorb road vibrations, offering a quiet and pleasant ride. This feature caters to drivers who value comfort during their journeys.

    The wheel sizes are from 4 to 8.50 making it an ideal choice for commercial turf equipment, consumer, golf carts, residential, and utility vehicles.

    Pros and Cons

    Before deciding whether to buy the Carlstar Turf Saver, let’s first drill down a few factors that can help you decide whether or not the tire is right for you.


    • Superior traction on various road surfaces, enhancing overall driving performance.
    • High-quality construction contributes to the tire's longevity, ensuring a reliable and lasting investment.
    • Drivers can enjoy a smooth and comfortable ride, thanks to the tire's ability to absorb road vibrations effectively.
    • While Carlstar makes a good claim about Turf Saver’s performance, some shortcomings may divide opinions.


    • Limited to lawn and garden applications only
    • The tire cannot be used on paved roads
    • The tread design has weather constraints and can’t be used year-round

    SimpleTire’s view on Carlstar Turf Saver tires

    With this tire, you are getting the same excellent performance, durability, and value that Carlstar has had for the past 100 years. Known as one of the most popular turf tread tires, Carlstar tires are used as original equipment for lawn mowers built by popular mower manufacturers like John Deere, Toro, and Jacobson.

    These tires are a great fit for garden tractors, walk-behinds, golf carts, snow blowers, turf maintenance vehicles, and utility vehicles. You see innovative tread which provides superior grip without damaging the grass underneath. The broad-shouldered design and extra-wide footprint help you maintain stability. This tire understands your need to protect your lawn without compromising on traction. This tire stands out with a commendable SimpleScore of 7.7, featuring a 7.8 for handling, a 7.9 for longevity, and a 7.7 for traction.

    Vehicles the Carlstar Turf Saver is a good replacement tire for

    This tire is an ideal choice for a wide range of vehicles such as lawnmowers, golf carts, tractors, and utility vehicles for its minimal grass compaction.














    17 SimpleTire reviews

    Verified Customer
    Oct 16, 2021

    Bought lawnmower tires.. excellent quality, don't tear up my grass as much as the original ones! Very pleased with my purchase

    Verified Customer
    Aug 25, 2020

    I am very pleased with the Carlisle tires for my John Deere LA-155 riding lawnmower. You cannot beat the quality, price, and speed of delivery given by SimpleTire. I am a regular customer for my residential, commercial, industrial, agricultural, and personal needs because of those three things. Simply, Ollie Millican, TX

    Verified Customer
    Aug 17, 2020

    These tires are great! So much better than what came on the tractor. I love simple tire. They are great bargains never disapointed

    Walker Lynn
    Verified Customer
    Aug 15, 2020

    I am very pleased with my tire will order some more thinking about some for my pickup got fast delivery will recommend simple tire to others

    Verified Customer
    Oct 3, 2019

    all the tires I buy ,have always done the job.We drive on concrete and turf and everything in between .Heavy loads of sand all weather condition's

    Verified Customer
    Jun 1, 2019

    OEM tire. Works good as new! Great service and fast delivery, just in time for the mowing season! Thanks!!

    Verified Customer
    May 3, 2019

    This is a very good company to order tires from. With about a 2 day turnaround with no tax and no shipping, this made my order great. These tires on my Toro zero turn are much better than the original tires.

    Verified Customer
    May 6, 2018

    These tires were identical to those that my 11-year-old lawn tractor came equipped with. After 11 seasons of mowing the tread was still good but the sidewalls deteriorated, resulting in long cracks and air leakage. Normal rubber deterioration, as far as I'm concerned.

    Verified Customer
    Jul 22, 2016

    Very nice quite tire

    Verified Customer
    Jun 19, 2015

    Great tires, lots of traction

    Write a review