Rims not included with purchase of tires
Carlstar

Carlstar All TrailReviews

Write a review
  • SimpleScore™

    Our proprietary rating system
    for the modern tire buyer.

    9.3

    Excellent

    Score breakdown:

    9.5

    Long lasting

    Excellent

    8.9

    Handling

    Great

    9.6

    Traction

    Excellent

  • 4 reviews

    4 on SimpleTire

    4.5

    overall rating

    100%

    Would you buy again?

    Review breakdown

    • 1 out of 100
    • 3 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100

    Carlstar Tires is a premier tire supplier that specializes in specialty tires that are designed for OTR, industrial, ATV, construction, and lawn/turf applications. The brand has been in the tire manufacturing business for over 100 years and has established itself as the leading tire manufacturer for difficult-to-find tires and ensures top-quality for all its products at affordable prices.

    The Carlstar All Trail tire is a trail tire designed to offer great traction on various road surfaces. In this Carlstar All Trail review, we will take a look at some of the features and benefits of the tire, its pros and cons, and SimpleTire’s views on the tire.

    Features and Benefits

    Trail Tires are designed for use on off-road terrains and are commonly used on ATVs, UTVs, and SxS. These tires feature aggressive tread patterns to ensure strong traction and performance in off-road terrains such as mud, dirt, and sand. These tires can resist damage as they are reinforced and have robust construction.

    The Carlstar All Trail is designed for use on ATVs and UTVs and excels on hard surface conditions. It is the industry’s first purpose-built hard-surface application tire and utilizes different tire elements that add to the value of the tire. Here are some noteworthy features and benefits of the All Trail.

    • Enhanced performance: The wide square footprint boosts traction and enhances stability for a reliable performance.
    • Robust construction: Comes with durable and damage-resistant casing to protect the tire for a longer tread life.
    • Enhanced handling: The optimized tread pattern boosts handling and traction performance.
    • Innovative design: The floatation design prevents the tire from getting stuck in the mud, while the low, wide profile helps reduce soft wallowing chassis roll.

    The Carlstar All Trail is designed for use on ATVs, SxS, and UTVs for use on hard-pack and intermediate surfaces and is available in different tire sizes ranging from 10 to 14 inches.

    Pros and Cons

    Now that we know more about the features and benefits of the Carlstar All Trail, let’s also take a look at some of the pros and cons of the tire to help you make a clearer decision.

    PROS:

    • Excellent design with enhanced overall performance.
    • Optimized for traction, handling, and durability.
    • Specializes in use on hard surfaces.

    While these pros make a good case for the tire, consider these cons before making a final decision.

    CONS:

    • The wet performance could have been better.
    • It should not be used in heavy winter weather conditions.
    • The tire can be a bit noisy on paved and unpaved roads.

    SimpleTire’s view on Carlstar All Trail tires

    If you are looking for a set of trail tires for your ATVs or UTVs designed with unique design and consistent performance, the Carlstar All Trail might be a good fit for you. These tires are designed to deliver smooth and reliable performance with durable construction for long-lasting performance. Due to these features and elements, the Carlstar All Trail has scored an average SimpleScore of 9.3 out of 10. The tire truly excels in traction (9.6) and longevity (9.5) and is not far behind in durability (8.9).

    You can also take a look at the Kenda K500 Super Turf, which offers an average SimpleScore of 9. The tire trumps All Trail in durability (9 v 8.9) and lacks traction (9) and longevity (9). However, it makes up for a significant price difference and is considerably more affordable.

    Vehicles the Carlstar All Trail is a good replacement tire for

    Carlstar All Trail is available in different tire sizes, so it can be used as a great replacement tire for different vehicles, such as John Deere Gator, Yamaha Viking, Kawasaki Tecate, Can-Am DS450, and more.

    Scorecard

    Dry

    4.8

    Wet

    4.3

    Winter

    4.3

    Comfort

    4.5

    Noise

    4.5

    Treadwear

    4.5

    4 SimpleTire reviews

    Ryan
    5
    Verified Customer
    Jul 12, 2020

    Great deal on golf cart tires. Easy transaction. Very happy!

    David
    4
    Verified Customer
    Aug 25, 2018

    Put these on a Can-Am Commander max. Am very satisfied. Road noise is low. Wear seams good. Little more squirly on dry loose material than stock tires but not bad. Traction is good on all surfaces encountered so far. 1700 miles and little wear.

    Denis
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Dec 21, 2015

    denise
    4.5
    Verified Customer

    great tires for my 4 wheeler. the last ones lasted me about 3 seasons of riding every weekend.

    Write a review