Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires

A sturdy shell, strengthened sidewalls, and rim protection are just a few of the features that are vitally necessary for mud-terrain tires to fulfill their purposes. Most of them also include self-cleaning tread, which helps clear away sand, mud, and other debris as you go. Although Pirelli has been a household name associated with UHP tires, it has recently stepped into the world of mud-terrain tires. Similarly, the Nexen Roadian MTX was launched as recently as 2017, although Nexen has been known for producing products at its state-of-the-art plants.

The addition of both these product lines makes light trucks and SUVs more capable, especially on off-road terrain. A ply rating of 10 for the Roadian MTX, as compared to 6 for the Scorpion MTR makes the former more capable of carrying heavier weights and lesser chances of being damaged due to high pressure. While the Scorpion MTR gets reinforced sidewalls and rim protection for high strength, the Roadian MTX features a 3-ply sidewall and an F load range. Make use of our detailed comparison to decide which is the most suitable tire for your vehicle.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires

As a mud-terrain tire, the Pirelli Scorpion MTR has a strong sidewall and is squishy. The tire might not be as noisy as many people on the internet may claim, and its design makes it appropriate for four-wheel-drive automobiles. To distinguish and symbolize the brand, a Scorpion is etched on the tire sidewall. When a car goes over bumps, the rigid sidewall gives off its actual color and ensures a firmer ride. The tire will feel sufficiently smooth both on and off the highway. Mud and debris are removed in part by a system of treads and grooves. These mud-terrain tires also include sipes, which further improve traction. With its distinct rubber formula and excellent tread depth, the tire is good for an average SimpleScore of 8.4.

Nexen Roadian MTX tires

Nexen Roadian MTX is an excellent choice if you’re searching for a versatile tire that allows capable on- and off-road driving. These tires feature a 3-ply design to increase hauling and durability capabilities. While an aggressive tread pattern enables it to provide high on- and off-road traction, a dual sidewall design allows buyers to choose the most attractive appearance. A patented tread block design is responsible for decreasing noise and vibrations, leading to a quiet and comfortable ride. Nexen also offers a comprehensive warranty program, the details of which will be given later. Overall, it scores a great 8.2 SimpleScore rating.

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on traction

Large transversal grooves and an aggressive high-void tread help the Pirelli Scorpion MTR remove dirt and debris, keeping a clear area of the tire ready for optimal traction at all times. Along with high tread depth, the extensive network of sipes increases grip. A self-cleaning pattern channels gravel out of the tread for secure and consistent traction. The Scorpion MTR provides tremendous traction on muddy, sand, gravel, and snowy surfaces, resulting in an exceptional average traction SimpleScore of 9.6.

On the other hand, an aggressive tread pattern enables the Nexen Roadian MTX to generate superior traction on mud, sand, dirt, and other surfaces. This tire has a lower tread depth when compared to the Scorpion MTR, which may translate into more confidence on the paved road. Based on the above features, this tire gets an average traction SimpleScore of 8.1.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on durability

The Pirelli Scorpion MTR tires are optimized to provide a cushioned and firm ride. While its sturdy construction keeps the tire harder on various surfaces, its reinforced sidewalls and rim guard guarantee exceptional endurance. With a Q-speed rating and an average durability SimpleScore of 9.2, the tire is best suited for 4x4 vehicles.

Compared to the above, the Roadian MTX features a rugged design that makes it highly durable. An F-Load load range and a 3-ply design ensure that it behaves like a heavy hauling tire. This tire also receives a Q-speed rating and deserves an average durability SimpleScore of 8.2. The Roadian ATX is a tire preferred by many enthusiasts, and high durability is a major reason for this preference.

ADVANTAGE: Pirelli Scorpion MTR

Pirelli Scorpion MTR vs Nexen Roadian MTX tires on longevity

The Pirelli Scorpion MTR's durable construction, tread pattern, and special tread compound are some of its many features. As previously indicated, the Scorpion MTR receives an average longevity SimpleScore of 7.6, indicating that the quality of the rubber and tread compound are important factors.

In comparison, the high tread depth and 10-ply rating are most helpful in increasing tread life. Nexen’s Total Coverage Warranty, inclusive of a 45-day or 500-mile trial period and 36 months of Roadside Assistance, is available here. The aggressive tread pattern enables this tire to take on difficult terrain, and it is good enough for an average longevity SimpleScore of 8.5.

ADVANTAGE: Nexen Roadian MTX

When to use each

Both, the Scorpion MTR and the Roadian MTX belong to the mud-terrain tires category, which means these tires are particularly designed to provide drivers traction on off-road terrains like mud, dirt, sand, gravel, and rocks. Whether you want to crush the trails or drive in deep mud, these tires are a great choice. They can also be taken on pavement but this doesn’t mean that they are great on the on-road performance part. Their core strength is to serve in challenging off-road conditions. Additionally, they shouldn’t be considered for regular driving on dry or wet pavement, and shouldn’t also be considered for use in wintry conditions in sub-freezing temperatures to drive on snowy or icy roads.

Which one should you choose?

Pirelli is known to make the most expensive tires in a lot of cases, and the same can be seen here as well. We found the Pirelli Scorpion MTR to begin at a price of $222.97 ($891.88 for 4). At the same time, the prices of the Nexen Roadian MTX start from $214.96 ($859.84 for 4).

Therefore, to summarise the comparison, you must select the Pirelli Scorpion MTR if:

• You are primarily looking at great traction in mud and sand
• You desire a tougher tire
• You need ride quality that is a mix of soft and hard
• You want a mix of great handling on pavement and good road manners

As against the above, here are the reasons for choosing the Nexen Roadian MTX:

• You want a more comprehensive warranty program
• You want longer tread life
• You want the cheaper tire
• You are looking for a quiet mud-terrain tire

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, and our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.