Firestone All-Season vs Cooper ProControl tires

When it comes to choosing the best all-season tires from the American tire manufacturer, Firestone and Cooper always cross our minds, thanks to their century-old legacy of producing some of the world’s finest tires in all these years. The Firestone and Cooper, now owned by different global players, still enjoy the same reputation for rolling out world-class tires.

Owned by Bridgestone, Firestone manufactures tires under different categories, including all-season, all-terrain, UHP all-season, winter, mud-terrain, and other tires. Similarly, Cooper Tire, owned by German tire giant Continental, also has quality tires for coupes, sedans, SUVs, CUVs, minivans, and light trucks.

For today’s comparison, we’ve picked the Firestone All-Season and the Cooper ProControl, which are designed for sedans, coupes, and CUVs and promise great year-round performance and a longer service life without a premium tag. While the Firestone All-Season is built upon a legacy of durability and utility, featuring a practical symmetric tread pattern and a rubber compound engineered for balanced wear and confident wet braking, the Cooper ProControl emphasizes advanced control and technology. Launched as a successor to Cooper’s acclaimed touring line, the ProControl utilizes newer-generation silica compounds and innovative groove technology to enhance grip and stability in wet and light snowy conditions.

So, which one to go for? Let’s do the Firestone All-Season vs Cooper ProControl tires comparison on the basis of performance of these tires on key attributes like traction, handling, and longevity using our proprietary SimpleScore, which is a scoring mechanism that rates each characteristic on a scale of 0-10.

Firestone All-Season tires

The Firestone All-Season, launched in 2017 as the successor to the FR710, is a reliable touring tire developed for coupes, sedans, and minivans. Backed by a strong 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, the All-Season returns consistent traction across dry roads, wet conditions, and light snow, thanks to its symmetric tread pattern featuring multiple sipes and deep grooves.

With an optimized tread design, the Firestone all-season tire returns accurate steering response, stability, and control, along with increased comfort and reduced noise levels on highways. Built with a reinforced construction and rubber compound, the Firestone All-Season focuses on tread life and confident performance for everyday commuting.

With a solid 8.4 overall SimpleScore, the Firestone All-Season stands out as a practical choice for varied driving conditions.

Get Firestone All-Season tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Cooper ProControl tires

The Cooper ProControl was developed specifically as an all-season tire for passenger cars. Thanks to its asymmetrical tread pattern and four circumferential grooves, this tire achieves year-round performance with improved wet and dry traction. With widening siping technology, the Cooper all-season tire continues to deliver great grip and traction even as the tire wears over time. Backed by a special silica rubber compound, the ProControl returns a longer service life. While the lateral grooves provide enhanced wet performance by clearing water from the surface, the Cooper all-season tire promotes accurate handling and stability in dry, wet, and light snow. For added peace of mind, the Cooper ProControl is covered by a 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

Scoring an 8.8 in its overall SimpleScore, the Cooper ProControl assures great year-round performance with a superb tread life.

Get Cooper ProControl tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Firestone All-Season vs Cooper ProControl tires on traction

Whether it’s a wet, dry, or snowy surface, tire traction is extremely important for safe journeys, making it the most vital aspect of tire buying. The Firestone and Cooper tires promise great all-season performance and are neck and neck in traction capabilities.

Achieving an 8.4 traction score, the Firestone All-Season utilizes a symmetric tread design to return improved grip and traction in dry, wet, and light wintry conditions. The incorporation of deep, strategically placed sipes across the entire tread area plays an active role in delivering extra biting edges for reliable traction and secure grip, particularly on highways and paved roads.

On the other hand, the Cooper ProControl scores the same 8.4 in traction and gives us a glimpse of how tightly fought this battle is going to be. Thanks to its circumferential grooves with connected grooves that help mitigate the risk of hydroplaning and improve wet braking and grip. The Cooper all-season tire utilizes a silica-rich tread compound and an asymmetrical pattern to improve grip in wet conditions. Additionally, widening sipe technology allows for increased traction to be maintained throughout the tire's life.

With the same scores, the Firestone All-Season and Cooper ProControl offer similar grip and traction on paved roads and end this section in a tie.

ADVANTAGE: Tie

Firestone All-Season vs Cooper ProControl tires on handling

The more command you have over the steering, the safer the driving is. The All-Season and ProControl provide adequate control and steering response; however, unlike traction, one tire has a slight advantage over the other. Let’s do the handling analysis.

The Firestone All-Season scores a notable 8.4 in handling, assuring drivers of decent steering response and great control. Its design, which includes a continuous center rib and solid shoulder design, improves stability and quick lane-changing ability. These features come together to boost performance during high-speed maneuvers and in various driving conditions, including dry, wet, and light snow.

With a fantastic handling score of 8.6, the Cooper ProControl provides a crisp steering response and superb control thanks to its reinforced construction, which includes steel belts and larger polymers in the rubber compound to increase strength and stiffness. Moreover, the Cooper tire also features an optimized tread design that strategically balances pressure during road contact.

With a better handling score, the Cooper ProControl proves to have better “control” on the steering than the Firestone All-Season.

ADVANTAGE: Cooper ProControl

Firestone All-Season vs Cooper ProControl tires on longevity

For all-season tires, longevity is among the most critical aspects. In fact, drivers choose all-season tires for their long-lasting tread and a longer service life. Both the all-season tires here promise superb tread life, but one of the two offers exceptional performance when it comes to wearability.

The Firestone all-season tire's highest score in this comparison is an 8.7 in longevity. This extended service life is achieved primarily through its deep siped design, which effectively curbs irregular wear and promotes a uniform wear pattern. The solid backing of 65,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty further assures excellent wear throughout its service life.

Going over the board, the Cooper ProControl returns an incredible 9.4 longevity score, which guarantees many future years without the need to swap tires. The ProControl features wear extending technology that bears large polymers to reinforce the rubber compound to provide excellent wearability. Moreover, the Cooper all-season tire is covered by a 70,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty.

Securing an outstanding score, the Cooper ProControl beats the Firestone All-Season comprehensively in the longevity battle.

ADVANTAGE: Cooper ProControl

When to use each

All-season tires are designed to offer excellent traction, grip, handling, and stability in dry, wet, and light snow. In addition, these tires are backed by all-season rubber compounds that last longer and remain unaffected in changing weather conditions.

Both the Firestone All-Season and Cooper ProControl are great all-season tires. If you prefer exceptional tread life and handling with adequate traction, the Cooper ProControl is an ideal option to go for. The Firestone All-Season is a decent option for drivers wanting a jack of all trades kinda tire.

Which one should you choose?

To sum up, the Cooper ProControl beats the Firestone All-Season 2-0 as it wins the handling and longevity section. While in the traction tussle, the two are neck and neck. However, choose a tire that’s more in sync with your needs and driving habits, as each tire carries unique characteristics. Let’s get to the final round of comparison, which is most important (for the majority of tire buyers): the price.

Comparing the prices of the 215/55R17 94V tire size, the Firestone All-Season costs around $147 per tire, and four such tires cost $588, while the Cooper ProControl costs around $178 per tire, and four such tires cost $712 (a difference of $124).

Based on SimpleScore, you should choose the Firestone All-Season if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Toyota Corolla, Honda CR-V, and the Chevrolet Impala
• Want great traction and handling
• Want an affordable yet capable all-season tire with decent tire with a longer mileage

Conversely, you should choose the Cooper ProControl if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Audi TT Quattro, Buick Skylark, and the Honda Civic
• Want a superb all-season tire with better handling (8.6 vs 8.4)
• Prefer an all-season with outstanding tread life (9.4 vs 8.7)

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.