Armstrong Blu-Trac HP vs BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires

The legendary American brand, Armstrong, is known for its wide range of reliable tires under different categories like all-season, all-terrain, highway, mud-terrain, all-weather, ultra-high-performance, and commercial. Now a unit of ZAFCO International, Armstrong rolls out tires for passenger cars, light trucks, SUVs, and CUVs.

Similarly, BlackHawk is a rapidly growing budget brand that offers great quality tires at reasonable prices. Marketed by Sailun, BlackHawk also has a wide portfolio of similar tire types and categories as that of Armstrong’s. For drivers wanting capable highway terrain tires, the Blu-Trac HP from Armstrong or the Street-H HH11 from BlackHawk make for a great deal.

In the budget-performance category, the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP and the BlackHawk Street-H HH11 challenge the premium brands at a fraction of their costs. While the Armstrong tire is positioned as a refined, stability-focused summer tire that offers precise handling and wet-weather confidence, BlackHawk’s Street-H HH11 is a powerhouse designed for the daily commuter who refuses to compromise on agility.

So, which one is the best tire for you? Let’s do the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP vs BlackHawk Street-H HH11 comparison based on their performance in SimpleScore. It’s our in-house scoring mechanism that rates each tire on a scale of 0 to 10 for traction, handling, and longevity traits. Read on.

Armstrong Blu-Trac HP tires

Designed for coupes, sedans, SUVs, and CUVs, the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP is a capable ultra-high-performance all-season tire that offers improved handling, grip, cornering, and traction year-round. With an asymmetric tread design, the Armstrong tire features four wide circumferential grooves that work in tandem with lateral grooves to quickly remove water and regain traction in wet and slick conditions.

While sub-straight grooves within the shoulder improve cornering and steering response, the silent grooves wall reduces road noise for a quiet and comfortable ride quality. Backed by a fantastic 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, the Blu-Trac HP comes with a 30-day money-back guarantee, road hazard repairs, 24/7 roadside assistance, and a 6-year limited warranty.

With an 8.1 overall SimpleScore, the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP assures solid grip, traction, handling, and longevity in different driving conditions, including dry, wet, and light snow.

Get Armstrong Blu-Trac HP tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires

The BlackHawk Street-H HH11 is an all-season tire that comes with some high-performance tire sizes for passenger cars and SUVs. Thanks to its all-season rubber compound, the tire is able to deliver consistent grip, traction, handling, and longevity in dry, wet, and light snowy conditions. With a modern non-directional tread design, the Street-H HH11 returns low rolling resistance for high fuel efficiency alongside an optimized tread design for reduced noise and vibration levels.

For extra durability, the high-performance tire features a jointless bead cover, which improves structural rigidity for a smooth ride. Backed by a solid 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty, the BlackHawk Street-H HH11 also comes with roadside assistance and 2-year road hazard coverage.

Securing an 8.0 in its overall SimpleScore, the BlackHawk Street-H HH11 assures solid year-round reliability with encouraging cornering, traction, acceleration, durability, and service life.

Get BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires at the best deals for your vehicle here

Armstrong Blu-Trac HP vs BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires on traction

A performance car demands superior grip, and to entertain such speed, a quality UHP all-season tire is what’s needed. A tire offering consistent traction improves your driving experience significantly throughout the year. Armstrong and BlackHawk fight it till the end in the traction race. Let’s see who wins it.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac HP scores 8.0 in traction, and it is tuned for performance-oriented driving. This tire features multiple sipes across the inner ribs, which provide extra biting edges, thereby improving grip in dry, wet, and light winter conditions. You also get four wide circumferential grooves, which help to evacuate water, mitigating the risk of hydroplaning. Drivers enjoy confident acceleration and braking, particularly at higher speeds.

The BlackHawk Street-H HH11 also scores 8.0 in traction, but you’ll experience more stability and consistency while driving. Thanks to the dense sipes across the tread, you’ll enjoy improved grip in wet and light winter conditions. The silica-based compound, on the other hand, improves traction but doesn’t compromise on efficiency. The design of this tire feels predictable and reliable, although it’s not as performance-oriented as the Armstrong.

With neck-and-neck performance, the traction tussle between tires ends in a tie.

ADVANTAGE: Tie

Armstrong Blu-Trac HP vs BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires on handling

UHP all-season tires must offer decent handling, as that’s what determines the steering response you experience. Proper handling also determines the kind of stability and comfort you feel while driving.

At 8.3, the handling score of the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP looks great, and you’ll get a sporty feel while driving. It features sub-straight grooves on the outer shoulders, which significantly improve precision while cornering. On the other hand, the asymmetric tread design makes your rides stable when you change lanes or drive at high speeds. Drivers feel more responsive and controlled as they push harder.

The BlackHawk Street-H HH11 earns a handling score of 8.0, and this tire focuses more on comfort. It features a solid center rib, which improves stability when you drive in a straight line, while the non-directional tread pattern makes your handling smooth and predictable. It offers a decent performance for daily driving, but your control wouldn’t be as sharp as that of the Armstrong.

Securing higher ratings, the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP is a better option in terms of handling.

ADVANTAGE: Armstrong Blu-Trac HP

Armstrong Blu-Trac HP vs BlackHawk Street-H HH11 tires on longevity

If you use your car daily, longevity should be an important factor to consider when you buy a UHP all-season tire. Long tread life, along with consistent wear, can significantly impact the overall performance of the tire. One of the tires scores better and wins the race to tread life.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac HP scores 8.4 in longevity and comes with a 45,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. Its tread design and durable rubber compound balance performance and longevity, and it wears steadily over time. It’s a great option for drivers looking for performance and a decent lifespan.

The BlackHawk Street-H HH11 scores 8.0 in longevity, but it offers a longer 60,000 mile limited manufacturer tread life warranty. The non-directional tread ensures even wear, and it’s a suitable choice for long-term use on a regular basis. Buyers get the assurance that it lasts longer under normal driving conditions.

The Armstrong Blu-Trac HP is the better pick in terms of longevity, as it bags a higher SimpleScore in this parameter.

ADVANTAGE: Armstrong Blu-Trac HP

When to use each

UHP all-season tires offer superior braking and better handling round the year, which makes them ideal for performance cars and sedans. Drivers enjoy better steering response and sporty handling with these tires.

Both these UHP all-season tires can be used throughout the year, but they are suitable for different driving styles. If you prefer a more engaging driving experience, the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP would be a suitable choice as it offers sharper handling and better cornering. Altogether, it gives you a sportier driving experience.

If you want a tire that provides you with a higher comfort level, the BlackHawk Street-H HH11 would be a better option. It’s suitable for longer highway drives and is a viable pick for drivers who want consistent performance.

Which one should you choose?

When you choose one of these tires, consider what you want from it based on your driving habits and preferences. The Armstrong Blu-Trac HP should be the better choice if you want better handling (8.3 vs. 8.0) and longevity (8.4 vs. 8.0). With this tire, you are likely to enjoy a more responsive driving experience. It’s suitable for drivers who want better performance at a reasonable price tag.

The BlackHawk Street-H HH11, on the other hand, delivers better long-term value with its longer warranty (60,000 miles vs. 45,000 miles). If you want comfort, it’s a suitable choice for everyday use. Drivers who value durability over sportiness must go for this tire.

For the 185/55R15 tire size, each Armstrong Blu-Trac HP tire costs around $53, and the price of four such tires is $212. On the other hand, the cost of each BlackHawk Street-H HH11 is around $67, which brings the cost of four such tires to approximately $268 (a difference of $56).

Based on SimpleScore, you should go for the Armstrong Blu-Trac HP if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Volkswagen Jetta, Ford Fiesta, or Hyundai Ioniq
• Want better handling (8.3 vs 8.0)
• Are looking for better longevity (8.4 vs. 8.0)
• Want an affordable yet capable UHP all-season tire

On the other hand, you may consider buying the BlackHawk Street-H HH11 if you:

• Drive vehicles like the Toyota Corolla, Kia Optima, or the Nissan Altima
• Want a longer warranty (60,000 miles vs. 45,000 miles)
• Value consistency over sportiness

Still not sure which tire to buy? Fortunately, SimpleTire is here to help, as our helpful agents are more than happy to assist you in selecting the right tire for your ride and budget.