Rims not included with purchase of tires
Carlstar

Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1Reviews

Write a review
  • SimpleScore™

    Our proprietary rating system
    for the modern tire buyer.

    8.0

    Great

    Score breakdown:

    8.6

    Long lasting

    Great

    7.6

    Handling

    Good

    8.5

    Traction

    Great

  • 132 reviews

    32 on SimpleTire100 from Google Shopping

    4.6

    overall rating

    91%

    Would you buy again?

    Review breakdown

    • 19 out of 100
    • 12 out of 100
    • 1 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100

    Formerly called Carlisle, Carlstar Tires is based in Franklin, TN, and manufactures high-quality specialty tires for lawn & garden applications, ATVs/UTVs, farm applications, trailers, industrial applications, and golf carts.

    The Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 is an all-purpose tractor tire engineered to offer solid traction and lateral stability. The tire is suitable for use on compact utility tractors and features a solid bias-ply tube-type construction. Carlstar has optimized this farm & agricultural tire to perform in both dry and wet conditions and gets a durable compound and reinforced casing.

    If you’re in search of the best compact utility tractor tire, then consider going through this Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 review and checking out the tire’s features, pros and cons, competitors, and our view on this tire.

    Features and Benefits

    Farm or Ag tires are suitable for use on tractors, sprayers, trailers, harvesters, implement control, and various other farm applications. They reduce soil compaction, ensure high flotation, and resist damage. The Farm Specialist R-1 falls in the same category and is suitable for use on compact utility tractors. This tire is equipped with many great features and is capable of performing with outstanding capacity when it comes to operating in farmlands. Let’s find out what features it has got and how they benefit.

    • Solid durability – The Farm Specialist R-1 gets a durable construction that protects the tire from cuts, chips, and abrasions. Its solid casing and tough rubber compound ensure that the tire can withstand during farm operations.
    • Maximized puncture resistance – All thanks to the heavy-duty sidewall and robust profile, the Farm Specialist R-1 can ensure maximized puncture resistance and also prevent the tire from unwanted damage.
    • Dependable traction performance – The Farm Specialist R-1 features an overlapping center tread lug that boosts traction in dry and wet conditions. Additionally, the multi-angle long-bar tread of the tire provides aggressive performance, lateral stability, and dependable traction while performing farm tasks.
    • Enhanced load capacity – The size lineup of this tractor tire is optimized for increased load capacity, thanks to its robust rubber compound formulation and strong carcass. The tire’s load capacities can range between 735 lbs to 4080 lbs.
    • Better self-cleaning – The tread of this agri tire is engineered to promote self-cleaning. The bigger gaps between the lugs do not allow dirt or mud to accumulate on the footprint and the advanced rubber compound doesn’t let wet dirt stick on the tread for long to ensure optimum surefootedness.
    • Smooth rides – Made in the USA, the Farm Specialist R-1 also offers smooth rides as it features an overlapping center tread lug that makes rolling seamless on any given farmland.

    The Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 is offered in the following tire sizes:

    Pros and Cons

    Now, let’s head over to learn the strengths and weaknesses of the Farm Specialist R-1 to help you make a well-informed decision.

    PROS:

    • Engineered for long-lasting service.
    • Solid traction performance in wet and dry conditions.
    • Offered in a good number of sizes to match the compatibility with a wide variety of tractor applications.
    • Available in moderate to high load capacities, depending on sizes.
    • The overlapping center tread lug design offers smooth rolling.
    • Optimized for self-cleaning.
    • Sturdy sidewalls boost puncture resistance.
    • More affordable than many of its competitors.

    CONS:

    • Some competitors offer more durable choices.
    • Doesn’t come with any tread life warranty.

    SimpleTire’s view on Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 tires

    If you’re looking for an all-purpose compact utility tractor tire, then the Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 is one of the most value-for-money choices in the market. It is comparatively more affordable than its competition and offers a long-lasting service, which is also indicated by its 8.6 SimpleScore rating for longevity. The traction performance of the tire is also impressive, especially in wet and dry conditions, and the same is highlighted through the tire’s 8.5 out of 10 SimpleScore rating in this area.

    For increased compatibility with a wide variety of compact utility tractor applications, Carlstar offers it in a good number of sizes. The tire is also good when it comes to carrying higher load capacities and features a unique overlapping center tread lug that allows it to roll very smoothly. The tread of the tire is optimized for self-cleaning and the sturdy sidewalls resist punctures, cuts, and chips.

    However, when compared to the competition, the Farm Specialist R-1 is average when it comes to durability and scores 7.6 out of 10 SimpleScore rating. Lack of tread life warranty coverage could be a downside for tread life warranty-conscious tire buyers.

    The Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 competes with the following tires in the market:

    Vehicles the Carlstar Farm Specialist R-1 is a good replacement tire for

    The Farm Specialist R-1 could be a good replacement choice for a wide variety of compact utility tractor applications.

    Scorecard

    Dry

    4.9

    Wet

    4.8

    Winter

    4.7

    Comfort

    4.6

    Noise

    4.4

    Treadwear

    4.8

    32 SimpleTire reviews

    Christopher
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 15, 2020

    Installed on a New Holland TC33DA. They are a stiff tire for a light tractor but carry a load extremely well. Dry traction is very good. Wet traction excellent. I would definitely purchase again. Easy order. Fast shipping.

    George
    5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 15, 2020

    I cannot give you a answer on how the tires perform at this time, only used them on light duty: I like the looks of them and the deep tread: Mounted them myself and realized there was a lot of tire there: Well built! Simple tire was great, tires delivered in two days on weekend: These were farm tractor tires so cannot answer your following questions: Certainly won't be racing with them!

    William
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Jul 31, 2020

    Nice set of tires!

    Grace
    5
    Verified Customer
    May 22, 2020

    The tires were easy to mount. They were just what I needed and I plan to buy rear tires for my tractor.

    Dave
    5
    Verified Customer
    Jan 5, 2019

    These tires are for my Kubota tractor. I haven't used them much yet, but I think they are great so far!

    David
    5
    Verified Customer
    Sep 27, 2018

    Great tires

    David
    5
    Verified Customer
    Sep 26, 2018

    Best tires at the best price at simple tire. Very satisfied!

    Rick
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 28, 2018

    Great tire, Great price. Will buy again when in need. Thanks

    Luther
    5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 25, 2018

    Great tires

    Kevan
    4
    Verified Customer
    Aug 25, 2018

    This was a FRONT tire for my Kubota TRACTOR, so these review categories really do NOT fit. I liked the heavy carcass quality of the tire, plus the tread design, which is important when I'm working in the forest, or plowing heavy snow in Winter. The price was better than any of our local outlets. Thanks Simple Tire.

    Write a review