Rims not included with purchase of tires
Carlstar

Carlstar AT489Reviews

Write a review
  • SimpleScore™

    Our proprietary rating system
    for the modern tire buyer.

    7.8

    Good

    Score breakdown:

    7.7

    Long lasting

    Good

    7.9

    Handling

    Good

    7.9

    Traction

    Good

  • 232 reviews

    26 on SimpleTire206 from Google Shopping

    4.6

    overall rating

    85%

    Would you buy again?

    Review breakdown

    • 15 out of 100
    • 9 out of 100
    • 1 out of 100
    • 1 out of 100
    • 0 out of 100

    Do you have a quad, SXS, or ATV? Are you in need of a durable, versatile tire that’s suitable for a wide variety of surfaces and applications? The Carlstar AT489 might be the tire you’re looking for. It’s durable and tough and suitable for a variety of terrains and surfaces. There are a lot of ATVs, SxS, and quad tires out there on the market, but we think this tire is a great value and a great performer. Let’s go in for a closer look with this Carlstar AT489 review:

    Features and Benefits

    Here’s what the AT489 has within it to allow for great performance:

    • Tough damage-resistant rubber formulation and casing protects the tire from punctures, cuts, abrasions
    • Directional lug tread enhances traction and performance by self-cleaning dirt and debris so there’s always a clear section of the tire to dig in as the wheel turns
    • Can be used at lower inflation pressure for rock crawling and better ride quality
    • Bias construction
    • Rounded shoulder design for responsive handling and precise cornering
    • Good flotation properties – designed to distribute vehicle weight and prevent sinking on soft surfaces

    Pros and Cons

    So, is this Carlstar tire the right choice for your ride and budget? Before you decide, let’s take a look at the tire’s pros and cons:

    PROS:

    • Affordable
    • Good ride comfort
    • Aggressive tread delivers great traction and self-cleaning
    • Can be used aired-down

    CONS:

    • Not competition grade
    • Not DOT-approved for street use

    SimpleTire’s view on Carlstar AT489 tires

    ATVs are more than a lot of fun – for hunters and explorers, they’re an extremely practical way to get around rough terrain and go places that would be pretty inaccessible without one. For those kinds of situations, the Carlstar AT489 is a perfect solution. The directional lug tread is versatile enough for traction on mud, sand, loose dirt, or hardpack, with good control and braking as well as tenacious grip. The 3-ply construction and damage-resistant tread compound gives you the confidence you need, knowing that the Carlstar AT489 can negotiate logs, rocks, brush, and debris without worrying about cuts and punctures.

    It’s a real bonus when an ATV tire can be used aired-down with low inflation – it allows the tire to conform to irregular or rough surfaces like rocks and logs for dependable and positive traction. That’s not to even mention the fact that lower inflation pressure means a more accommodating ride for the driver. The extra-deep tread of the Carlstar AT489 boosts traction on a variety of surfaces, with flotation that helps a rider get through soft terrain without sinking in and digging ruts. That said, the Carlstar AT489 isn’t designed for deep, heavy mud and isn’t DOT-approved for street use. Still, especially considering its affordable price, we think that the Carlstar AT489 is a great option for a variety of applications and a wide range of ATVs, SxS, and quad machines.

    Vehicles the Carlstar AT489 is a good replacement tire for

    Here’s a list of quads and ATVs that would be a good fit for the Carlstar 4-Max:

    • Yamaha YFZ450
    • KTM 450X
    • Honda TRX250R
    • Honda TRX450R
    • Suzuki LTR450
    • Can-Am DS450
    • Kawasaki KFX450R
    • Kawasaki Mule
    • Honda TRX400
    • Suzuki Quad Sport LTZ400
    • Yamaha Raptor 700R
    • Yamaha Banshee
    • Kawasaki Tecate
    • Polaris Outlaw 525 IRS
    • Can-Am Outlander
    • Can-Am Renegade
    • Honda Fourtrax Rancher
    • Yamaha Kodiak 450
    • CF Moto CForce 400
    • Polaris Sportsman 570

    Scorecard

    Dry

    4.8

    Wet

    4.8

    Winter

    4.6

    Comfort

    4.7

    Noise

    4.6

    Treadwear

    4.4

    26 SimpleTire reviews

    Patrick Usher,
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Oct 30, 2021

    Patrick Usher,
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Oct 30, 2021

    Tim
    5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 18, 2020

    Great tires great price.Quick delivery. Thanks

    William
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 16, 2020

    Really like the way the tires ride on rough roads

    Joseph
    4.5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 9, 2020

    I just purchased these tires a couple of months ago, so I cant comment on tread wear or winter effect. I have been pleasantly surprised by the sound and comfort of ride, because these tires are more aggressive than the ones I replaced.

    Michael
    5
    Verified Customer
    Aug 5, 2020

    Great tires! Easy and smooth transition. Very fast shipping! I will definitely order from here again!

    george
    5
    Verified Customer
    Jul 28, 2020

    Quick delivery.

    Christopher
    3.5
    Verified Customer
    Jul 27, 2020

    Larry
    2.5
    Verified Customer
    Jul 19, 2020

    M
    5
    Verified Customer
    Jun 1, 2020

    Great side by side tires. Great pricing. Great service from Simple Tire. I also just got a hard to find car tire from Simple Tire in just two days.

    Write a review